RIP School Survival Forums
August 2001 - June 2017

The School Survival Forums are permanently retired. If you need help with quitting school, unsupportive parents or anything else, there is a list of resources on the Help Page.

If you want to write about your experiences in school, you can write on our blog.

To everyone who joined these forums at some point, and got discouraged by the negativity and left after a while (or even got literally scared off): I'm sorry.

I wasn't good enough at encouraging people to be kinder, and removing people who refuse to be kind. Encouraging people is hard, and removing people creates conflict, and I hate conflict... so that's why I wasn't better at it.

I was a very, very sensitive teen. The atmosphere of this forum as it is now, if it had existed in 1996, would probably have upset me far more than it would have helped.

I can handle quite a lot of negativity and even abuse now, but that isn't the point. I want to help people. I want to help the people who need it the most, and I want to help people like the 1996 version of me.

I'm still figuring out the best way to do that, but as it is now, these forums are doing more harm than good, and I can't keep running them.

Thank you to the few people who have tried to understand my point of view so far. I really, really appreciate you guys. You are beautiful people.

Everyone else: If after everything I've said so far, you still don't understand my motivations, I think it's unlikely that you will. We're just too different. Maybe someday in the future it might make sense, but until then, there's no point in arguing about it. I don't have the time or the energy for arguing anymore. I will focus my time and energy on people who support me, and those who need help.

-SoulRiser

The forums are mostly read-only and are in a maintenance/testing phase, before being permanently archived. Please use this time to get the contact details of people you'd like to keep in touch with. My contact details are here.

Please do not make a mirror copy of the forums in their current state - things will still change, and some people have requested to be able to edit or delete some of their personal info.


Post Reply 
 
Thread Rating:
  • 1 Vote(s) - 5 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Do the ends justify the means?
Author Message
dreamer... Offline
Pariah

Posts: 563
Joined: Jan 2008
Thanks: 0
Given 5 thank(s) in 3 post(s)
Post: #1
Do the ends justify the means?

Warning: this is gonna be a long post.

So, I just finished watching Minority Report (awesome movie btw) and it raises a very interesting question. In the movie, three individuals endure extreme suffering- not by choice- in order to save thousands of lives. My question: is this morally wrong? If those three were relieved from their suffering, many people would die. Yes, the needs of the many outweigh the needs of the few, but how far should we go in pursuing the needs of the many? Is it right to force those few into agony to save the thousands of lives at stake? Or should the three be spared the pain and liberated, regardless of the terrible consequences? If they are subjected to suffering for the greater good, do they have any right to refuse? What if those few must die? I guess this is just another case of “do the ends justify the means”. And honestly, i'm not sure what I think. The cost of personal freedom (to refuse the suffering) seems so great…perhaps there are times when a few individuals must be sacrificed for the benefit of a larger group…well, I don’t really know.
What do you guys think?
03-27-2008 12:42 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
HeartofShadows Offline
Fanatic

Posts: 8,557
Joined: Dec 2006
Thanks: 0
Given 80 thank(s) in 73 post(s)
Post: #2
Re: Do the ends justify the means?

I've seen minority report.. it was a cool movie.
In real life sometimes the ends justifies the means depending on the ends.
As for minority report the pre crime system was a shitty system that never took into account free thought.
There are plenty of times I've wanted to kill people and commit unspeakable crimes and yet I talk myself out of it.
The pre crime system arrests me before i even have a chance to think about the crime.

[Image: WARZONES_subs_hostility.png]
image hosting jpg
03-27-2008 01:51 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
NiteRaidah Offline
hmmm

Posts: 1,061
Joined: Jun 2007
Thanks: 25
Given 44 thank(s) in 31 post(s)
Post: #3
Re: Do the ends justify the means?

Like HoS said, it depends on the ends....

Would it be worth it to, say, suffer for a while just for something miniscule, like a passing grade on a test?

Granted, that's perhaps not the best example, though.

"All these computers and digital gadgets are no good. They just fill your head with numbers and that can't be good for you."
-Prince

[Image: USVWSwj.png]
03-27-2008 04:00 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Double Offline
Revolutionary

Posts: 340
Joined: Sep 2007
Thanks: 0
Given 1 thank(s) in 1 post(s)
Post: #4
Re: Do the ends justify the means?

Yes.

And No.

In a big scenario like the one in Minority Report I would never let the ends justify the means. It's just stupid, some people making a job on imprisoning thoughtful people and keeping 3 young girls floating in a water container.
However, I think there are times when the ends must justify the means. It's not always an easy decision to make, I can imagine, but I also suppose there are thousands of different positions you can find yourself in, and ask yourself the same question, every time.

Also, in Minority Report things are very exaggerated and thus the Idea of the ends justifying the means becomes a bit twisted after watching the movie. Still a good movie though.
03-27-2008 06:16 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
dreamer... Offline
Pariah

Posts: 563
Joined: Jan 2008
Thanks: 0
Given 5 thank(s) in 3 post(s)
Post: #5
Re: Do the ends justify the means?

i don't mean do the ends justify the means specifically in the movie, but just in general. You guys said "it depends"- so, in your opinions, when is it okay to make a few people suffer to help the greater good? When is it not ok?
03-27-2008 11:02 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
SoulRiser Offline
Site Founder

Posts: 18,240
Joined: Aug 2001
Thanks: 2673
Given 1979 thank(s) in 1209 post(s)
Post: #6
Re: Do the ends justify the means?

How 'bout this really horrible example...

You're standing next to a train track. The person you care about most in the entire universe is tied to the tracks. There's a switch where you can make the train use a different track, which will make it avoid the person. The train is coming, there is no time to untie the person. The other track you can make the train go on is broken, and the train will fall off the cliff and everyone aboard will die (say, 100 people or so). What do you do?

There's no guarantee the 100 people on that train are intelligent, interesting, or even remotely good in any way. I mean, if it was a train with 100 politicians in it... there'd be no question, really. Mwahaha
But you just don't know.

"If you can, help others; if you cannot do that, at least do not harm them." - Dalai Lama
Help & Support - Get help with leaving school, unsupportive parents, and more.
Click here if school makes you depressed or suicidal

Support School Survival on Patreon or Donate Bitcoin Here: 1Q5WCcxWjayniaL92b8GfXBiGdfjmnUNa2
"Believe those who are seeking the truth. Doubt those who find it." - André Paul Guillaume Gide
"The true sign of intelligence is not knowledge but imagination." - Albert Einstein
"I'm pretty sure there's a lot of beauty that can only be found in the mind of a lunatic." - TheCancer
EIPD - Emotionally Incompetent Parent Disorder

Push Button for Collection of Useful Links:
Hidden stuff:
03-27-2008 01:38 PM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Bob Dole Offline
Fanatic

Posts: 2,631
Joined: Feb 2007
Thanks: 0
Given 23 thank(s) in 19 post(s)
Post: #7
Re: Do the ends justify the means?

I'd waste a hundred people.

K
S
03-27-2008 03:18 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
liq3 Offline
Fanatic

Posts: 2,240
Joined: Mar 2007
Thanks: 0
Given 22 thank(s) in 16 post(s)
Post: #8
Re: Do the ends justify the means?

Anonymous1.0 Wrote:I'd waste a hundred people.

Epic win book.
Personal Development for Smart People.
03-27-2008 04:09 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Jonno Offline
Pariah

Posts: 890
Joined: Sep 2007
Thanks: 0
Given 4 thank(s) in 4 post(s)
Post: #9
Re: Do the ends justify the means?

Anonymous1.0 Wrote:I'd waste a hundred people.
You'd do that even if there was no-one tied to the tracks
03-27-2008 04:36 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Bob Dole Offline
Fanatic

Posts: 2,631
Joined: Feb 2007
Thanks: 0
Given 23 thank(s) in 19 post(s)
Post: #10
Re: Do the ends justify the means?

Thonil Wrote:
Anonymous1.0 Wrote:I'd waste a hundred people.
You'd do that even if there was no-one tied to the tracks
Nah. If it was somebody I loved I would let 100 people die. Or the entire world. Somebody I didn't know or disliked, pull up a chair.

K
S
03-27-2008 05:13 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Suicidal-kun Offline
Fanatic

Posts: 4,541
Joined: Jul 2007
Thanks: 0
Given 19 thank(s) in 18 post(s)
Post: #11
Re: Do the ends justify the means?

Oh I'd let the 100 fuckers on the train die without a second thought or hesitation if it meant saving the most important person to me.
03-27-2008 05:41 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
dreamer... Offline
Pariah

Posts: 563
Joined: Jan 2008
Thanks: 0
Given 5 thank(s) in 3 post(s)
Post: #12
Re: Do the ends justify the means?

Suicidal-kun Wrote:Oh I'd let the 100 fuckers on the train die without a second thought or hesitation if it meant saving the most important person to me.

That's a very selfish thing to do. Not that I wouldn't do the same...but I can't really say what I would do in the train scenario- that is one hell of a traumatizing situation and there's no way I would be thinking clearly!

But...when I think of it logically...I guess I would let the friend die (ok, i would look for alternatives, but we're assuming there are none). That person might mean everything to me, but the 100 on the train mean just as much to their loved ones. So yeah, I suppose I'd save the 100 and sacrifice my friend.
03-27-2008 06:53 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
liq3 Offline
Fanatic

Posts: 2,240
Joined: Mar 2007
Thanks: 0
Given 22 thank(s) in 16 post(s)
Post: #13
Re: Do the ends justify the means?

@dreamer : You could also consider it selfish that the 100 would sacrifice your friend for themselves.

Also, going my beliefs, it's the peoples fault for getting on the train. It's their time to die, whether they like it or not.

Epic win book.
Personal Development for Smart People.
03-27-2008 07:58 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Suicidal-kun Offline
Fanatic

Posts: 4,541
Joined: Jul 2007
Thanks: 0
Given 19 thank(s) in 18 post(s)
Post: #14
Re: Do the ends justify the means?

dreamer... Wrote:
Suicidal-kun Wrote:Oh I'd let the 100 fuckers on the train die without a second thought or hesitation if it meant saving the most important person to me.

That's a very selfish thing to do. Not that I wouldn't do the same...but I can't really say what I would do in the train scenario- that is one hell of a traumatizing situation and there's no way I would be thinking clearly!

But...when I think of it logically...I guess I would let the friend die (ok, i would look for alternatives, but we're assuming there are none). That person might mean everything to me, but the 100 on the train mean just as much to their loved ones. So yeah, I suppose I'd save the 100 and sacrifice my friend.
Hey, I never said I wasn't a selfish person. I just don't value the life of 100 random people compared to the life of the person most special to me.
03-27-2008 08:20 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
HeartofShadows Offline
Fanatic

Posts: 8,557
Joined: Dec 2006
Thanks: 0
Given 80 thank(s) in 73 post(s)
Post: #15
Re: Do the ends justify the means?

This is coming from a guy who would turn his back on the world for the one most important to him. compared to 100 people I wouldn't give a shit. Humans are greedy by nature and although you say that it will be a hard choice think of this dreamer. Living life with the one most important to you beside you or 100 people who wouldn't even give a shit about what you went through to save them.

I guess the ends justifying the means depends on the person's attachment to the means.

Another shitty example(Soulriser yours was good)
I got this from swordfish but what if you could stop all suffering and pain in this world put you would have to kill a school full of kids for a sacrifice in a horrible and bloody way could you.

[Image: WARZONES_subs_hostility.png]
image hosting jpg
03-28-2008 06:20 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Suicidal-kun Offline
Fanatic

Posts: 4,541
Joined: Jul 2007
Thanks: 0
Given 19 thank(s) in 18 post(s)
Post: #16
Re: Do the ends justify the means?

Well, in that situation HoS, I would have to say, sucks to be those kids, for I'd probably kill them.
03-28-2008 09:21 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
dreamer... Offline
Pariah

Posts: 563
Joined: Jan 2008
Thanks: 0
Given 5 thank(s) in 3 post(s)
Post: #17
Re: Do the ends justify the means?

Quote:what if you could stop all suffering and pain in this world put you would have to kill a school full of kids for a sacrifice in a horrible and bloody way could you.

Uhoh That's a hard question...
Noo
so instead of answering I'm gonna argue that this example doesn't make sense. Killing the kids would lead to a lot of pain and suffering on behalf of the parents. Instead of stopping the suffering in the world it would create more... so yeah. i say the example is irrational.
03-28-2008 09:50 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Suicidal-kun Offline
Fanatic

Posts: 4,541
Joined: Jul 2007
Thanks: 0
Given 19 thank(s) in 18 post(s)
Post: #18
Re: Do the ends justify the means?

dreamer... Wrote:
Quote:what if you could stop all suffering and pain in this world put you would have to kill a school full of kids for a sacrifice in a horrible and bloody way could you.

Uhoh That's a hard question...
Noo
so instead of answering I'm gonna argue that this example doesn't make sense. Killing the kids would lead to a lot of pain and suffering on behalf of the parents. Instead of stopping the suffering in the world it would create more... so yeah. i say the example is irrational.
Its a hypothetical question, it doesn't have to be rational.
03-28-2008 09:54 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Bob Dole Offline
Fanatic

Posts: 2,631
Joined: Feb 2007
Thanks: 0
Given 23 thank(s) in 19 post(s)
Post: #19
Re: Do the ends justify the means?

Lock and load. Time to go Cho.

K
S
03-28-2008 11:43 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
HeartofShadows Offline
Fanatic

Posts: 8,557
Joined: Dec 2006
Thanks: 0
Given 80 thank(s) in 73 post(s)
Post: #20
Re: Do the ends justify the means?

Dreamer notice I didn't say what kinda kids.
Especially if it was high school kids I would think about it.
Depends on what kinda mode I'am in but then again I could give a shit about the world so ehh.
But think about world peace for a school full of kids.

[Image: WARZONES_subs_hostility.png]
image hosting jpg
03-28-2008 02:45 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
SoulRiser Offline
Site Founder

Posts: 18,240
Joined: Aug 2001
Thanks: 2673
Given 1979 thank(s) in 1209 post(s)
Post: #21
Re: Do the ends justify the means?

Let's change this a bit. If you had to kill everyone on SS for world peace, would you do it?

"If you can, help others; if you cannot do that, at least do not harm them." - Dalai Lama
Help & Support - Get help with leaving school, unsupportive parents, and more.
Click here if school makes you depressed or suicidal

Support School Survival on Patreon or Donate Bitcoin Here: 1Q5WCcxWjayniaL92b8GfXBiGdfjmnUNa2
"Believe those who are seeking the truth. Doubt those who find it." - André Paul Guillaume Gide
"The true sign of intelligence is not knowledge but imagination." - Albert Einstein
"I'm pretty sure there's a lot of beauty that can only be found in the mind of a lunatic." - TheCancer
EIPD - Emotionally Incompetent Parent Disorder

Push Button for Collection of Useful Links:
Hidden stuff:
03-28-2008 03:00 PM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
dreamer... Offline
Pariah

Posts: 563
Joined: Jan 2008
Thanks: 0
Given 5 thank(s) in 3 post(s)
Post: #22
Re: Do the ends justify the means?

You know, Heart of Shadows, you have a good point. With the train scenario I could easily decide what to do, but with the schoolkids I hesitate.

The two scenarios are different in that the train one is passive- someone will die no matter what, I have to choose if it's 1 or 100 people. But I'm not killing anyone, just picking the lesser of 2 evils.

With the schoolkids scenario though, it is active...I would be murdering, intentionally. Part of me says world peace would be worth those lives, but another part reminds me that killing is a horrible crime. I don't think I ever have any right to take someone else's life for the greater good. Unless I got the kids to agree to sacrifice their lives...then, it might be justifiable. Well, i'm leaning towards no, save the kids...but as I said, I really just don't know.

Wow, your question really makes you think!
03-28-2008 03:06 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
HeartofShadows Offline
Fanatic

Posts: 8,557
Joined: Dec 2006
Thanks: 0
Given 80 thank(s) in 73 post(s)
Post: #23
Re: Do the ends justify the means?

Ok on school survival.

I would kill wolf, maybe thunder, Darthmat, and Thats all.
(Just Joking)

In all seriousness nah I could kill you guys if I knew you.
(If I had amnesia though...

[Image: WARZONES_subs_hostility.png]
image hosting jpg
03-28-2008 03:08 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
HeartofShadows Offline
Fanatic

Posts: 8,557
Joined: Dec 2006
Thanks: 0
Given 80 thank(s) in 73 post(s)
Post: #24
Re: Do the ends justify the means?

I would say Zero and rebelnerd but Rebenlnerd is the kinda guy that if he was going to die would take you with him and he might blow me up and Zero just ain't human.

Oh and thanks dreamer.

[Image: WARZONES_subs_hostility.png]
image hosting jpg
03-28-2008 03:09 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Suicidal-kun Offline
Fanatic

Posts: 4,541
Joined: Jul 2007
Thanks: 0
Given 19 thank(s) in 18 post(s)
Post: #25
Re: Do the ends justify the means?

SoulRiser Wrote:Let's change this a bit. If you had to kill everyone on SS for world peace, would you do it?
Nope, I couldn't kill you guys, especially one particular member.
03-28-2008 07:15 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Post Reply 


Possibly Related Threads...
Thread: Author Replies: Views: Last Post
  Am I the only one terrified by what this means? Kirby 7 1,438 01-07-2010 12:36 PM
Last Post: The Desert Fox

Forum Jump:


User(s) browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)

Contact Us | School Survival | Return to Top | Return to Content | Mobile Version | RSS Syndication